Captive Agent vs. Independent Agent
A captive agent sells policies for a single insurance company, while an independent agent can quote and place policies with multiple carriers. The difference affects how much comparison shopping happens on your behalf.
By submitting, you agree to be contacted by phone, text, or email about your project, including by automated means, even if your number is on a do-not-call list. Consent is not a condition of purchase. See our Privacy Policy and TCPA Compliance page for details.
Assigners CommitmentYour request is only shared with a service provider matched to your project and service area — never sold as part of a bulk or resold list.
Captive Agent
An agent who represents one insurance company exclusively and can only offer that carrier's products and pricing.
- Deep familiarity with one carrier's specific products and discounts
- Often backed by a large company's claims infrastructure and brand support
- Can't compare your rate against other carriers directly
- If that carrier's pricing isn't competitive for your profile, you won't know it from this agent alone
Independent Agent
An agent who works with multiple insurance companies and can compare quotes across carriers to find pricing and coverage that fits your situation.
- Can shop your profile across several carriers at once
- May place different lines of coverage — auto, home — with different carriers if that's cheaper overall
- Doesn't always have access to every carrier in the market
- Larger direct-to-consumer insurers may not work with independent agents at all
Which one makes sense for you?
An independent agent can offer a broader comparison across carriers, which is useful if your profile doesn't fit a single insurer's sweet spot. A captive agent can still be competitive, particularly if that specific carrier offers strong discounts for your situation, such as an existing relationship or bundling opportunity.
Key cost factors.
- Number of carriers an agent or agency actually represents
- Complexity of your household — multiple drivers, vehicles, or a driving violation
- Whether you value a single point of contact or the widest possible comparison
- Local availability of independent agencies in your area
Before you decide.
- How many carriers does this independent agent actually quote?
- Does the captive agent's carrier offer any discounts I'd miss elsewhere?
- Who handles claims support after the policy is placed?
Frequently asked questions.
Does an independent agent cost more than going direct to a captive agent?
Agent commissions are generally built into the premium either way, so working with an independent agent typically doesn't add extra cost — you're paying for the comparison shopping, not an additional fee on top.
All figures on this page are illustrative examples for general education, not quotes, appraisals, or guarantees of actual pricing. Actual costs vary by provider, location, project scope, and market conditions — always get a specific quote before making a purchasing decision.
Selling in insurance?
Talk to our sales team about sourcing exclusive, real-time leads, warm transfers, and inbound calls.